MGS1 vs MGS3 vs Metal Gear 1+2 – Which Remake Would be Better?

The Metal Gear Solid franchise has undoubtedly made a significant impact in the video gaming industry with its innovative gameplay elements, gripping narrative, and iconic characters. As the series evolved, so did the graphics and mechanics, resulting in remakes for some of the earlier installments, including Metal Gear Solid 1 and 2 and Metal Gear 3: Snake Eater. While each of these remakes has its unique features and upgrades, the question remains: which is better among the three? In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at MGS1 vs MGS3 vs Metal Gear 1+2 to determine which remake reigns supreme.

MGS1 vs MGS3 vs Metal Gear 1+2 – Which Remake Would be Better?

Introduction

Remakes of classic games are becoming more and more common in today’s gaming industry. The latest rumor going around is that Konami, the company responsible for producing the beloved Metal Gear Solid franchise, is currently in the process of developing a remake of one of their classic games. But which one? And which one would be better? In this article, we will take a closer look at Metal Gear Solid 1, Metal Gear Solid 3, and the combined Metal Gear 1 and 2, and determine which one would make for the best remake.

Metal Gear Solid 1 ##

Metal Gear Solid 1 is a beloved classic and marks the beginning of the iconic stealth franchise. With the game having been released over 25 years ago, it is understandable that some fans may be clamoring for a remake. At the same time, with the success of the Resident Evil 2 and Final Fantasy VII remakes, it seems like the perfect time to bring Metal Gear Solid 1 into the modern gaming era.

Pros

  • Metal Gear Solid 1 has a fantastic story that has stood the test of time.
  • The game’s characters, such as Solid Snake, have become iconic figures in the gaming industry.
  • The gameplay mechanics could be improved upon to fit today’s standards.

Cons

  • The game’s graphics have not aged well and would need a complete overhaul.
  • The narrative structure may be difficult to adapt to modern standards.

Overall, a Metal Gear Solid 1 remake would be a risk, but ultimately could pay off with the right team behind it.

Metal Gear Solid 3 ##

Metal Gear Solid 3 is often considered the “fan favorite” for many fans of the franchise. It has a visual style and amazing story that have stood the test of time. A remake of Metal Gear Solid 3 would not be as daunting as overhauling Metal Gear Solid 1.

Pros

  • The game’s story is well-loved by fans.
  • The style and graphics have held up well with age.
  • The gameplay mechanics could be improved to fit today’s standards.

Cons

  • Changing too much of the game could upset fans.
  • A highly marketed remake may not bring in a lot of new fans.

Overall, a Metal Gear Solid 3 remake seems like the safest choice for Konami as it is widely beloved and would generate excitement for the franchise without the risk of major changes.

Metal Gear 1 and 2 Combined ##

A Metal Gear 1 and 2 combined remake reimagined as a modern AAA stealth experience could also be a risk but could receive more freedom to change things on a wider scale.

Pros

  • The game’s story has not been explored as much as the later games in the franchise.
  • Modernizing it would be a fresh take on a classic story.
  • The freedom to change things could create a new and unique experience for fans.

Cons

  • It may not be as well-known among newer fans.
  • Changing too much of the game could upset fans.

Overall, a Metal Gear 1 and 2 combined remake would be a big risk, but if done correctly could end up being a great experience for fans and new players alike.

Conclusion

In conclusion, each of these games would make for a fantastic remake, but they come with their own risks and rewards. Metal Gear Solid 1 would be a big risk that could pay off well with the right team behind it. Metal Gear Solid 3, on the other hand, seems like the safest choice for Konami to revive the franchise. Finally, a Metal Gear 1 and 2 combined remake reimagined as a modern AAA stealth experience could also be a risk. But it could be the fresh take that the franchise needs. It remains to be seen what Konami’s decision will be, but whichever game they choose, fans are sure to be excited.

FAQs ##

  1. Has Konami officially confirmed any of these remakes?

No, Konami has not confirmed any of these remakes.

  1. What studio is rumored to be developing the remake?

According to leaked reports, the remake is being developed by a studio which has spent the majority of its time working on ports and remasters.

  1. Will series creator Hideo Kojima be involved in any new Metal Gear Solid projects?

No, Kojima has parted ways with Konami and any new Metal Gear Solid project will be without him.

  1. How important is it that the remakes are in line with current gaming standards?

It is very important as gamers expect remakes to be up to par with current gaming standards.

  1. Which game do you think would make for the best remake?

That ultimately depends on the team behind the remake and how well they are able to execute their vision.

Scroll to Top